At 12 years old and 150,000 miles, her Expedition has certainly been around a while, but “old” isn’t the first thing that pops into my mind when I look at it. What I think of is how great it is to have a reliable vehicle with no car payment.
A recent headline shared that the average car payment in the US is now $551 over 69 months. With average household income just over $60k/yr, that means many households have more than 10% of their entire income going towards a car payment. Many people don't even keep their cars for 69 months, resigning themselves to having a car payment as long as they live.
Over the past several years, we've been fortunate to see our net worth grow quite quickly. While a relatively high income has certainly helped, just as important has been the way in which we've controlled our expenses. Behind housing, transportation related expense is often the next largest, but by not having car payments our transportation related costs have been a fairly small percentage of total income.
I've seen some pretty crazy justifications for car loans, but nothing will convince me that it's a good idea for me. Like the friend who couldn't afford a new set of tires, so instead just traded in her vehicle for a brand new one since the monthly payment would be less than 4 new tires. Seriously.
Or how about my coworker who brings in more than $200k per year and complains about still having student loans 12 years after graduation. Might it have something to do with having 3 car loans, and a self-proclaimed inability to keep a car more than 50,000 miles? Hope you like the Mercedes, buddy.
Earlier in our financial journey (2006 and 2007), we borrowed $20k and $14k for vehicles. While we had car payments it seemed that we were only treading water financially, despite having a household income of around $100k. In 2008 we sold the more expensive of the two, opting to be a one car household, and payed off the remaining car in February of 2009. We haven't had a car payment in over 10 years, and in that time have purchased 3 cars, all with cash.
With that background, here are some of the top reasons I love living without a car payment:
1. Lower Monthly Recurring Expenses - seems obvious, but it's freeing to be able to keep more of each of my paychecks and to not be playing catch up for purchases already made. Your income is the fastest way to build wealth, if you're able to actually save/invest it.
2. Option to Pay for Collision Insurance - since no one has a lien on my vehicles, I can choose whether to pay for collision insurance (often a very expensive addition) or not. If I had a loan, I wouldn't have that choice. We keep collision on my Lexus since I drive it more often and I don't want to run the risk of using up our cash to replace it if something happened. My wife's vehicle is only driven ~5,000 miles per year and has a low replacement value, so we save several hundred dollars per year waiving collision insurance.
3. Unlimited Miles - Although my wife doesn't drive much, I drive around 20,000 miles per year. The typical car lease includes only 10,000 to 15,000 annual miles before they charge you more per mile. I have friends who rent cars for road trips since it ends up being cheaper than paying for extra miles on their lease. We used to do a lot of fairly long road trips, and never once had to think about whether we had enough miles.
4. Easier to Budget for Repairs - even though cars tend to be more reliable today than they were 20+ years ago, things still break every once in a while. If you're paying a car payment, it's sometimes difficult to have the extra expense beyond the car payment itself.
5. I'll Never be Upside Down - It's been reported that as many as 1/3 of new car purchases include a trade-in with negative equity rolled into the new purchase. With people not keeping their cars long enough to even get equity in their vehicle they are further committing themselves to having a car payment for their entire lives. If I don't have a car loan, I'll never have to worry whether I'm upside down.